Insight
Founder-Led Sales

Hire the seller you would buy from: build a rubric

Stop hiring the best of the five people you interviewed. Hire the one you would buy from, and let a rubric make the call.

Written by
Charles Talbot, Founding Partner at Closing Foundry
Founding Partner
charles-talbot
Closing Foundry . Insight
Reviewed by
Published
June 21, 2026
Updated
Read time
3
Key Points
  • A rubric is a behaviour matrix, not a skills list.
  • The test: not best of the five, but I would buy from her, any day.
  • No starting point? Build it backwards from your one great hire.

If you are not a sales expert, hiring sellers feels like a guess. A simple rubric turns the guess into a decision.

A rubric is a behaviour matrix, not a skills list

Douglas Mancini's test for a good hire is blunt. After the interview you should not be saying she was the best of the five. You should be saying I would buy from her, any day. A rubric names the handful of behaviours that matter to you and lets you score candidates against them, so hiring stops being a gut call. If you do not know where to start, build it backwards: take your one great hire, look at the behaviours and skills that made them work, and map those.

It works for managing too. With a rubric you can self-score, compare, and have a fair development conversation at two or three months instead of hoping for the best.

Get the sales skills rubric (free in Resources), and see how it fits Strategic Sales Enablement.

The Revenue Workshop
60 minutes to work out what’s getting in the way of sales execution and what to fix first. No cost, operator-led.
Learn more →
Get the sales skills rubric
The behaviour rubric we use to hire and coach sellers. Free in Resources.
Open Resources

Insights

Architectural concentric-circle blueprint - enterprise deals and win rate.
Founder-Led
Cycle-cut

How do you actually reduce sales cycle length?

May 28, 2025
A row of identical dashboard screens - a repeatable sales process.
Founder-Led
Win-rate lift

How to Build a Repeatable, Buyer Centric Sales Process

July 2, 2025
A thumb adjusting a precision measurement dial - qualification and discovery.
Revenue Leader
Cycle-cut

7 Steps to Win Buying Group Consensus and Cut Deal Slippage

June 26, 2025